We've had a great run in the LED stocks recently, and that calls for a fresh look at the numbers to see how they're currently valued, and where they may be headed. Let's put aside the events of the past couple months and focus on the only question that matters now... "Would we buy these stocks if we just discovered them today?"
First, we have to estimate their growth potential and earnings growth timeline. From this standpoint, the LED stocks are still attractive. People have not yet even started to buy these products, and government regulations are soon going to force people to do so... worldwide. This suggests that the LED stocks still have a way to go. But what do the numbers tell us?
Going on the assumption that the actual earnings growth peak for these companies will occur when people first start buying these items in quantity, it suggests that these companies may not hit the top of their growth cycle for another 2 years or so. This means the stocks will hit their peaks in about 15 to 18 months (6 to 9 months before the earnings growth tops out).
Being conservative, the LED companies can be expected to grow approximately 20% to 25% a year over the next 3 to 5 years. This gives them fair P/E's of somewhere between 25 to 30.
VECO
Current EPS= -.22 -.15 + .16 + .41 = .20
Current P/E= 47/.20= 235
EPS in 3 mos= .16 + .41 + .46 + .54 = 1.57
P/E in 3 mos= 47/1.57= 30
CREE
Current EPS= .13 + .18 + .30 + .38 = .99
Current P/E= 77/.99= 78
EPS in 3 mos= .30 + .38 + .43 + .46 = 1.57
P/E in 3 mos= 77/1.57= 49
The above numbers show that while their current EPS's suggest that these stocks are way overvalued, a very different picture will emerge just a few months out. These numbers also suggest that CREE is about 65% more expensive than VECO. This makes sense, seeing as how the 800lb gorilla always attracts the most investors, and therefore carries the highest valuation.
It is our opinion that CREE is overpriced at $77 considering that if it stayed at its current price, it's P/E would be 30 in approx 9 months. That means that it will go sideways for the next 6 months or so before it has room to move higher. Don't believe it? Watch. It may go higher and then drop, or lower and then rally, or just go sideways. Either way, you'll be able to buy CREE at $77 again later this summer or in the Fall. There's no rush to jump in at its current price.
VECO, on the other hand, will have a P/E of 30 in just 3 months if it stays at its current price of $47. We would buy VECO here if we were just discovering it today. Even better if it corrects into the low 40's. The closer we can buy it near a P/E of 30, the better off we'll be in the long run. We're currently looking for an entry point for VECO, and to a lesser extent a re-entry point into CREE.
So where will these stocks top out? There are too many variables involved to give an answer to this question. And truth be told, nobody knows. But from where we stand now, the numbers suggest that at their peak, CREE and VECO could both be trading at approximately $100.
(assuming a P/E of 40 and an EPS of $2.50) It won't be long after their EPS's reach about $2.50 that widespread talk of lower margins, cheaper LED's, expiring patents, newer products, etc, will cause these stocks to put in a top.
If you want to really prepare for the LED craze, we suggest that you get yourselves margin accounts. When these stocks top out, they are going to fall very hard. Any company making products that can easily be duplicated cheaper in Singapore will crash in the end. This isn't a Google where the brand is irreplaceable. This is cut-throat competition for cheaper prices.
When these stocks begin their fall from grace, we will immediately discontinue our love affair with them and reverse course. The LED stocks will be headed to zero like all other stocks. But until then, let's enjoy the ride to $100 by setting up sniper posts and picking off a few shares here and there on those days when people just sell with passion for no reason whatsoever.